ARE THE SHRINKS ,WHO STILL CONTINUE THE 34 YEARS PSYCHIATRIC TORTURE OF MY DAUGHTER , FASCIST SADISTS OR ARE THEY CHRONIC PSYCHOPATHS ?

by Benjamin Merhav

There are numerous questions hanging over psychiatry and over the legal power invested in shrinks, its practitioners, to impose their "treatment" on people they declare "mentally ill". Questions such as : why does the law endorse the false claim by the shrinks that psychiatry is part of medicine when in reality psychiatry is no more than a fascist quackery ? And why does the law endorse the false claim by the shrinks that psychiatry is "treating the mentally ill" without even an iota of evidence, neither for the "mental illnesses" nor for the "need for psychiatric treatment"(see : http://18thoutlawpsychiatry.blogspot.com/2011/09/httpwww_28.html) ? And why does the state subsidises psychiatry and its state shrinks when there is clear proof that psychiatry is a fraud ( see : http://18thoutlawpsychiatry.blogspot.com/2011/08/dr_11.html), and that its subservience to the huge pharmaceutical corporations amounts to an international racket ?

These and many more questions which are detrimental to humanity have not been answered by the shrinks. Instead, they keep on telling lies with complete impunity, and with utter disregard for the numerous protests by their patient-victims, and even for other members of the medical profession who oppose psychiatry.

There are 228 posts on this blog alone which prove that psychiatry is a fraud, and that its history has been an ongoing barbaric and fascist series of atrocities and crimes against humanity. Some of these posts report the ongoing psychiatric atrocities against my daughter for 34 years and against my son for 20 years here , in Melbourne, Australia. All my complaints and protests on their behalf have been ignored with impunity, as the entire state apparatus, including the courts, are on the side of the shrinks. So much so that even the ombudsman has refused to investigate the complaints I submitted on their behalf to his office. As a result, the torture of my daughter and of my son continues unabated risking their well being and their lives. Thus, for example, I have pointed out to the Chief Psychiatrist here that according to recent research, life expectancy of long term patients on Antipsychotic drugs is reduced by 25 years; and even if they survive they are likely to get permanent brain damage ( see : http://18thoutlawpsychiatry.blogspot.com/2011/02/scientific-proof-antipsycho-tics-shrink.html ), but she rejected my complaint saying that such are the results of the "mental illness", not of the Antipsychotic drugs. In other words, the state's shrinks here are getting away with murder !

Following are 3 of my latest letters of comlaints/appeals on behalf of my daughter and of my son to the heads of psychiatry in Victoria, Australia :

1. http://18thoutlawpsychiatry.blogspot.com/2011/03/my-second-open-letter-to-minister-for.html

2. http://18thoutlawpsychiatry.blogspot.com/2011/09/my-appealcomplaint-to-minister-for.html

3. 11 November, 2011

Dr. Karleen Edwards Executive Director,

Mental Health and Drugs Division,
Department of Health, Vic. Melbourne

Dear Dr. Edwards,

I write to you on behalf of my daughter, Miss Rebeckah Merhav. This is not a formal letter to you, as I have had the opportunity to meet the Chief
Psychiatrist and my daughter's consultant psychiatrist yesterday, on
the 10th of November. Legally speaking, therefore, this could have been
the last resort, but justice and the well being of my daughter prompted
me to appeal to you for the help which I failed to get at that meeting.
Another reason for this appeal to you is your well known efforts for
amending/replacing the current Mental Health Act which would have helped my daughter get both the justice and the well being of which she has been deprived so far, if the new bill would have been in force as an act
of parliament at present.

This month marks 34 years since my daughter was first incarcerated in a
local psychiatric ward at the age of 15. Those have been, off and on,
mostly years of compulsory psychiatric treatment under CTO. I did
describe that during the above meeting yesterday, pointing out that all
those years of torture and suffering of my daughter have had no
justification - not morally, not medically-scientifically, and not even
according to proper psychiatric practice, as my daughter was never any
danger to the public nor to herself. This ongoing compulsory psychiatric
torture of my daughter for 34 of her best years of life have left her now unable to bear children nor form a family of her own, yet they still won't let go of her even now !

I did mention to the Chief Psychiatrist, who expressed her view that this
compulsory psychiatric "treatment" might continue for years to come,
that even if my daughter survives (which recent research proves very
doubtful following long years of Antipsychotics consumption) she would
get her brain damaged permanently as a result. In reply she said that my
daughter is mentally ill ("schizophrenic") therefore needs the
"treatment" she is getting, or else her situation would deteriorate. The
Chief Psychiatrist added that if my daughter gets brain damage it would
be the result of her "mental illness", rather than the result of the
Antipsychotic drugs.

My above meeting with the Chief Psychiatrist was a very polite and cordial meeting on all sides, and we parted as friends, strangely enough.
However, the views she expressed are very conservative, and long
outdated even by psychiatrists. These views have no scientific basis
whatsoever. Thus, for example, it is well known now that the average
lifespan of all long term psychiatric patients is reduced by 25%. It is
also well known now that long term use of Antipsychotics causes the
patients' brains to shrink permanently as an irreversible brain damage.
However, the most outrageous of all psychiatric wrongs is the
fundamentally unproven claim by psychiatry that there is such a thing as
"mental illness" for which psychiatry provides the "necessary
treatment". This is simply not true, and without any scientific
justification ! There is not one single "mental illness" which has been
discovered and proven by scientific methods, as is the general practice
amongst all medical specialties. All psychiatric illnesses have been invented by psychiatrists without providing any scientific proof of their existence.

During the above meeting with the Chief Psychiatrist I also pointed out that according to section 8(1) of the Mental Health Act, 1986, one necessary requirement for the issue of a CTO by a psychiatrist is that there is no alternative treatment available for the patient. In the case of my daughter I kept on pointing out repeatedly that she has several offers
for effective alternative therapies without the use of drugs, including
an offer by a Melbourne psychiatrist who had provided a written second
opinion too ! Yet , the Chief Psychiatrist refused to accept this
argument saying that any alternative therapy must be in addition to the
psychiatric "treatment" rather than to replace it.

Another issue I have raised during that meeting was the ban on any
communications between myself, as representative of my daughter, and the psychiatric clinic to which she is attached. This ban has been in force
since April 2008 as punishment for my complaints on behalf of my
daughter. This ban has been imposed in violation of the Chief
Psychiatrist Guidelines, but it is still on, and the Chief Psychiatrist
expressed her view that I should be allowed to contact the treating
psychiatrist not more than once a month.

The most urgent of all the issues I have raised there was the deprivation
of restful night sleep which my daughter suffers for six years now, ever
since she has been forced to consume the current dose of Clozapine and
Risperdal. This was an ongoing complaint by my daughter which has been
ignored by the relevant psychiatrists. This reason alone should be
sufficient for the gradual tapering off these drugs, but the
psychiatrists refused all my daughter's pleas, and the Chief Psychiatrist approves of their refusal.

I am sure that if this appeal on behalf of my daughter would be supported by yourself, Dr. Edwards, the Minister for Mental Health would be in favour of my daughter's call for help too. It could save her life and her well being.

Respectfully yours, Benjamin Merhav

=================

Obviously, the top state psychiatrists in Victoria Australia have shown complete disregard for my daughter (for 34 years now) and my son's sufferings (for 20 years now) under the psychiatric "treatment" forced on them by the local state shrinks. This attitude is tantamount to telling them that they have got to continue to suffer and risk their well being, and even death. The shrinks' pretext is that they are hallucinating, therefore they are "psychotic", therefore must continue to consume the deadly dangerous Antipsychotic drugs pushed to them by the shrinks. My explanations that in the case of my daughter her hallucinations are the result of the Antipsychotic drugs she is forced to consume; and in the case of my son he has been deliberately programmed by a zionist cult to go on fasting, therefore needs deprogramming, not Antipsychotic drugs, have not been considered by the shrinks. The subservience of psychiatry to the giant pharmaceutical corporations makes the shrinks insist on the compulsory "treatment" even if it would cause death or permanent brain damage to the patient-victims who survive.